An older running shoe can be worth considering when the fit is right and the price is sensible. The difficult part is telling a useful discount from a model that does not suit you. These five shoes appeared in our earlier roundup; they are older generations, not a list of the newest releases.
This comparison uses product information rather than a CHOOS wear test. It does not award a universal winner or claim that a shoe will treat an injury.
At a glance
| Model | What to compare | Check before buying |
|---|---|---|
| Brooks Ghost 15 | DNA LOFT v2 cushioning | Width and fit in the available size |
| Nike Pegasus 39 | React foam and Zoom Air units | Standard model versus Shield variant |
| ASICS GEL-KAYANO 30 | 4D GUIDANCE SYSTEM and FF BLAST PLUS ECO foam | Whether its support feel suits you |
| New Balance 1080v11 | Fit of this specific generation | Exact model, width and condition |
| Saucony Guide 13 | Fit of this older Guide model | Stock age, condition and returns |
Brooks Ghost 15
Brooks specifies DNA LOFT v2 cushioning for the Ghost 15. If you already wear a Ghost, compare the fit of this version rather than assuming each generation feels identical. A discounted pair is only useful if the available width and size work for you. See Brooks’ Ghost 15 information.
Nike Pegasus 39
The standard Pegasus 39 uses Nike React foam, Zoom Air cushioning and an engineered-mesh upper. Our previous description incorrectly called that upper Flyknit. Listings for the weatherised Shield model refer to a different variant, so compare the full product name. See Nike’s Pegasus 39 details.
ASICS GEL-KAYANO 30
The GEL-KAYANO 30 features the 4D GUIDANCE SYSTEM and FF BLAST PLUS ECO cushioning. That is a more useful description than assigning it to everyone with a particular arch shape. Comfort and support are individual; the product name alone does not establish that it is suitable for foot pain. ASICS documents the construction in its technical brochure.
New Balance 1080v11 and Saucony Guide 13
Both are older generations, so pay close attention to the exact listing. A review of a newer 1080 or Guide should not be treated as a review of these versions. Ask the seller about condition if stock has been stored for a long time. Avoid buying an unsuitable size just because it is the last discounted pair.
How to choose between them
Start with the shoes you find comfortable now: what would you keep, and what would you change? Compare the shortlisted pair indoors with your usual running socks. Check for pressure across the forefoot, heel movement and whether the upper feels secure without excessive lace tension.
Measure both feet and use the manufacturer’s chart. Confirm the return conditions before an outdoor run. Prices and stock vary, so this guide does not promise a particular saving.